Browning Hi Power vs 1911: Which is the Better Pistol?

Written by

Megusta

Browning Hi Power vs 1911

Browning Hi Power vs 1911 are two of the most popular pistols in the world. Both pistols have a rich history and were designed by the legendary gun designer, John Browning. These pistols have been used by military, law enforcement, and civilians for over a century.

The Browning Hi Power was designed in the 1920s and was one of the first pistols to use a double-stack magazine. It was originally designed for the French military, but it quickly became popular with other militaries and law enforcement agencies around the world. The Hi Power has a sleek design and is known for its reliability and accuracy.

The 1911, on the other hand, was designed in the early 1900s and was the standard sidearm for the US military for many years. It is a single-stack pistol that is known for its stopping power and accuracy. The 1911 has a classic design and is still a popular choice among gun enthusiasts today.

What is Browning Hi Power?

The Browning Hi-Power is a semi-automatic pistol that was designed by the American firearms inventor John Browning and later completed by Dieudonné Saive, a Belgian firearms designer.

It is often referred to as the “Hi-Power” or simply the “Browning.” The pistol was first introduced in the 1930s and has a storied history as one of the most influential and widely used handguns in the world.

Browning Hi Power
Browning Hi Power – Image Source: Nighthawk Custom

What is 1911 Pistol?

The 1911 pistol is a semi-automatic handgun that was designed in, you guessed it, 1911. It was developed by John Browning, one of the most influential firearms designers in history, and was adopted as the standard issue sidearm for the United States military from 1911 until 1985, when it was replaced by the Beretta M9.

1911 Pistol
1911 Pistol – Image Source: Accuracy X

Quick Comparison Table Between Browning Hi Power vs 1911

Feature Browning Hi Power 1911
Origin Belgium United States
Designer John Moses Browning John Moses Browning
Year of Creation 1935 1911
Action Short-recoil, single-action Short-recoil, single-action
Magazine Capacity Typically 13 rounds (in 9mm) or 10 rounds (in .40 S&W) Various capacities ranging from 7 to 10 rounds (standard models)
Caliber Options 9mm Parabellum, .40 S&W, .45 ACP (depending on the variant) .45 ACP, 9mm, .38 Super, 10mm (depending on the variant)
Frame Steel Steel or alloy
Grip Single-stack with checkered wood or synthetic grip panels Single-stack or double-stack with various grip options
Safety Mechanism Ambidextrous manual thumb safety Manual thumb safety, grip safety, and optional firing pin/blocking safety
Sights Fixed or adjustable sights Fixed or adjustable sights
Barrel Length Typically 4.6 inches (117mm) Various lengths ranging from 3 to 6 inches (depending on the variant)
Weight Typically around 2.4 lbs (1.1 kg) unloaded Varies depending on the model and materials used
Trigger Pull Typically around 4-5 lbs (1.8-2.3 kg) Typically around 4-5 lbs (1.8-2.3 kg)
Accessories Wide availability of aftermarket parts and accessories Wide availability of aftermarket parts and accessories
Military Service Used by various militaries and law enforcement agencies worldwide Widely used by the U.S. military and many other armed forces around the world

The Differences Between Browning Hi Power vs 1911 Pistol

History

History of Browning Hi Power vs 1911

The 1911 pistol, designed by John Browning, was adopted by the U.S. military in 1911 and is known for its .45 ACP caliber. It served as the standard-issue sidearm for nearly 75 years.

The Browning Hi-Power, also designed by Browning, was introduced in the late 1930s and is notable for its double-stack magazine and 9mm Parabellum chambering. It was adopted by various countries’ military and law enforcement agencies.

Design

Design of Browning Hi Power vs 1911
Design of Browning Hi Power vs 1911

Ergonomics: The Hi-Power has a more traditional grip angle, while the 1911 has a distinct grip angle designed to point naturally for many shooters.

Caliber: The 1911 was originally designed for .45 ACP, while the Hi-Power was initially chambered in 9mm. The 1911 has been adapted to various calibers more easily.

Safeties: The 1911 is known for its multiple safeties, including a manual thumb safety and grip safety. The Hi-Power typically has a manual thumb safety but lacks the grip safety.

Magazine Capacity: The Hi-Power typically holds more rounds in its magazine (13 rounds in 9mm) compared to the standard 1911 (7-8 rounds in .45 ACP).

Sight Options: The 1911 offers a wider variety of sight options, including adjustable sights and night sights.

Grip Design: The 1911’s grip is often appreciated for its ergonomics and checkering, while the Hi-Power’s grip is simpler and less aggressive.

Caliber and Capacity

Caliber and Capacity of Browning Hi Power vs 1911
Caliber and Capacity of Browning Hi Power vs 1911

Browning Hi-Power:

  • Caliber Options: The Browning Hi-Power is typically chambered in 9mm Parabellum (9x19mm) as its most common caliber. Some variants were also produced in .40 S&W, but 9mm is more prevalent.
  • Capacity: The standard capacity for a Browning Hi-Power magazine is typically around 13 rounds, but higher-capacity magazines are available, such as 15 or 20 rounds, depending on the specific model and country of manufacture.

1911:

  • Caliber Options: The 1911 is known for its chambering in .45 ACP (Automatic Colt Pistol), which is a larger and more powerful cartridge compared to the 9mm. However, the 1911 platform has also been adapted to other calibers like 9mm, .40 S&W, 10mm Auto, and more.
  • Capacity: The standard capacity for a traditional single-stack 1911 chambered in .45 ACP is typically 7 or 8 rounds. However, modern variants and double-stack 1911s can offer higher capacities, often ranging from 10 to 15 rounds depending on the magazine design and model.

Sights

Sights and Trigger of Browning Hi Power vs 1911
Sights and Trigger of Browning Hi Power vs 1911

Browning Hi-Power: The Browning Hi-Power typically comes with fixed sights. These sights are usually simple and may consist of a blade front sight and a notch rear sight. They are adequate for general target shooting and self-defense purposes, but they lack the adjustability and customization options found on many modern handguns. Aftermarket sights can be installed on the Hi-Power to improve sight picture and accuracy.

1911: The 1911 often features a variety of sight configurations. While many 1911s come with basic iron sights similar to those on the Browning Hi-Power, the 1911 platform is known for its flexibility when it comes to customization. You can find 1911s with adjustable target sights, night sights, and various sight options that can be tailored to the shooter’s preferences. This makes the 1911 a more versatile platform when it comes to sights.

Trigger

Browning Hi-Power: The Hi-Power is known for its single-action trigger. It typically has a crisp and relatively light trigger pull. The single-action trigger means that the hammer must be manually cocked before the first shot, and subsequent shots have a shorter and lighter trigger pull. This can contribute to better accuracy in the hands of an experienced shooter. The Hi-Power trigger is generally considered a good balance between safety and shootability.

1911: The 1911 is renowned for its trigger quality. It features a single-action trigger with a short, light, and consistent pull. The 1911 trigger is often praised for its “glass rod” break, which means it has minimal creep or take-up before the trigger releases. Many shooters find the 1911 trigger to be one of the best among handguns, and it’s often used as a standard of comparison for other firearms.

Size and Weight

Size and Weight of Browning Hi Power vs 1911
Size and Weight of Browning Hi Power vs 1911
Browning Hi Power 1911
Overall length 7.75 inches 8.25 inches
Barrel length 4.625 inches 5 inches
Height 5.375 inches 5.5 inches
Width 1.25 inches 1.25 inches
Weight (unloaded) 32 ounces 35 ounces

Browning Hi-Power:

  • Length: The Browning Hi-Power typically has a barrel length of around 4.7 to 4.9 inches.
  • Weight: The weight of a Browning Hi-Power is typically in the range of 2.1 to 2.2 pounds (32 to 35 ounces).

1911:

  • Length: The 1911 comes in various models, but the typical barrel length for a full-size 1911 is around 5 inches.
  • Weight: A standard 1911 full-size model usually weighs between 2.3 to 2.5 pounds (36.8 to 40 ounces).

Reliability and Durability

The reliability and durability of firearms are important factors to consider when choosing between different models. Here’s a comparison of the reliability and durability of the Browning Hi Power and the 1911:

Browning Hi Power 1911
  • The Browning Hi Power is known for its exceptional reliability and durability. It was designed to be a military sidearm and has been used by many military and law enforcement agencies around the world.
  • The Browning Hi Power has a solid steel frame and slide, which contributes to its durability. It also has a simple and robust design, with fewer parts than some other semi-automatic pistols.
  • The Browning Hi Power has a reputation for being able to handle a variety of ammunition types without issue, which further demonstrates its reliability.
  • The 1911 is also known for its reliability and durability. It has been used by the US military for over a century and has proven itself in many combat situations.
  • The 1911 has a steel frame and slide, which makes it a sturdy firearm. It also has a simple and robust design, with a relatively low number of parts.
  • The 1911 is often praised for its accuracy and precision, which is an important factor in its reliability.

Overall, both the Browning Hi Power and the 1911 are highly reliable and durable firearms. They are both made with high-quality materials and have a reputation for being able to handle a variety of conditions and ammunition types. Ultimately, the choice between these two firearms will likely come down to personal preference and the specific needs of the shooter.

Performance

When it comes to performance, both the Browning Hi Power and the 1911 are exceptional firearms. However, there are some differences between the two that are worth noting.

Browning Hi Power

The Browning Hi Power is known for its reliability and accuracy. It has a smooth trigger pull and a lightweight design, making it easy to handle and shoot accurately.

The Hi Power is also known for its high capacity magazine, allowing for up to 16 rounds of ammunition. This makes it a great choice for self-defense and target shooting.

One downside to the Hi Power is that it can be difficult to disassemble and clean. This can be frustrating for those who like to keep their firearms in top condition.

1911

The 1911 is a classic firearm that has been around for over 100 years. It is known for its accuracy and reliability, making it a popular choice for target shooting and self-defense. The 1911 has a crisp trigger pull and a heavy, solid feel that many shooters love.

One downside to the 1911 is that it has a relatively low capacity magazine, with a maximum of 9 rounds. This can be a disadvantage in self-defense situations where multiple shots may be necessary.

Another potential issue with the 1911 is that it can be finicky with certain types of ammunition. Some shooters have reported issues with feeding and ejecting certain brands or types of ammo. However, this can often be remedied with some tweaking and adjustments.

Popularity

Browning Hi Power 1911
  • The Browning Hi Power was first introduced in 1935 and has since gained popularity among military and law enforcement agencies around the world.
  • The firearm was used by many countries during World War II and the Cold War.
  • It has also been featured in numerous movies, TV shows, and video games over the years.
  • However, the popularity of the Browning Hi Power has declined in recent years due to the availability of newer and more advanced firearms.
  • The 1911 is a classic firearm that has been in production for over a century.
  • It has been used by military and law enforcement agencies around the world and is still in use today.
  • The 1911 has also gained popularity among civilian gun owners for its accuracy and reliability.
  • The firearm has been featured in numerous movies, TV shows, and video games, further cementing its place in popular culture.
  • The 1911 remains a popular firearm today, with many manufacturers producing their versions of the classic design.

FAQs

Q: Which pistol has a higher magazine capacity, the Browning Hi Power or the 1911?

A: In general, the Browning Hi Power has a higher magazine capacity. It typically holds 13 rounds in 9mm or 10 rounds in .40 S&W. The 1911, on the other hand, usually has a lower magazine capacity, ranging from 7 to 10 rounds depending on the specific model and caliber.

Q: Are there any differences in the safety mechanisms between the two pistols?

A: Yes, there are some differences. The Browning Hi Power typically features an ambidextrous manual thumb safety, while the 1911 usually has a manual thumb safety, grip safety, and optional firing pin/blocking safety. Both pistols have safety features designed to prevent accidental discharges.

Q: Which pistol is more widely used in military and law enforcement agencies?

A: Both pistols have seen extensive use in military and law enforcement agencies worldwide. The Browning Hi Power has been used by various armed forces and police units, while the 1911 has a long-standing history of service with the U.S. military and has also been adopted by many other armed forces globally.

Q: Can I customize and accessorize these pistols easily?

A: Yes, both the Browning Hi Power and the 1911 have a wide range of aftermarket parts and accessories available, allowing for extensive customization. You can find various grips, sights, triggers, extended magazines, and more to personalize your firearm to your liking.

Q: Which pistol is generally lighter in weight?

A: The weight of the pistols can vary depending on the specific model and materials used. However, in general, the Browning Hi Power tends to be lighter than the 1911.

The Hi Power typically weighs around 2.4 pounds (1.1 kg) unloaded, while the weight of the 1911 can vary depending on factors such as frame material and barrel length.

Q: What are the available caliber options for these pistols?

A: The Browning Hi Power is available in various calibers, including 9mm Parabellum, .40 S&W, and .45 ACP, depending on the specific variant. The 1911 is also available in multiple calibers, with the most common being .45 ACP. However, you can also find 1911 models chambered in 9mm, .38 Super, and 10mm, among others.

Conclusion

When it comes to choosing between the Browning Hi Power and 1911, it ultimately comes down to personal preference and intended use. Both pistols have their strengths and weaknesses, and what works for one person may not work for another.

For those who prioritize capacity and ease of use, the Hi Power may be the better choice. Its double-stack magazine allows for a higher round count, and its ergonomics make it comfortable to shoot for extended periods. Additionally, its 9mm chambering makes it a more affordable option for those who want to practice their shooting skills without breaking the bank.

On the other hand, those who prioritize stopping power and a proven track record may prefer the 1911. Its .45 ACP chambering is known for its effectiveness in self-defense situations, and the pistol’s long history of military service speaks to its reliability and durability. Additionally, the 1911’s single-stack magazine may make it easier to conceal for those who carry a firearm daily.

Ultimately, the decision between the Hi Power and the 1911 comes down to personal preference and intended use. Both pistols have their strengths and weaknesses, and both have proven themselves to be reliable and effective firearms over the years.

Last Updated on October 28, 2023 by Cecil B. DeMille

Leave a Comment